« Soderbergh Gets the Bronx Cheer | Main | Nativity Director Hardwicke Dresses for Pope »

Dreamgirls's Heavyweight Champs


[posted by Sheigh Crabtree]

I just got back from a "Dreamgirls" screening at DGA here in New York. The crowd really enjoyed it -- broke into enthusiastic applause during "And I'm Telling You." But I did listen in on a heated argument between two Broadway aficianados in the lobby afterward comparing the talents of Jennifer Hudson and Jennifer Holliday who very memorably played Effie on stage. One guy was arguing that Hudson was doing a poor woman's Aretha Franklin imitation and that Holliday is a superior talent. The other guy said that Holliday was not "more original" since she was impersonating Mahalia Jackson. Below I posted Holliday singing "And I'm Telling You" at the '82 Tonys. See both renditions and decide for yourself. (Scrub through to 3:33 for just Holliday)


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Dreamgirls's Heavyweight Champs:


Got something to say? There’s three exciting options:

  1. Comment instantly and anonymously below. Just enter a real (or fake, we don’t mind) name and email address below and hit "Post Comment." Email addresses remain private. OR--
  2. Check "Register with DISQUS." Same as #1, but you can create a profile, add a photo, vote on comments and more. OR--
  3. Use Facebook. Click the "F Connect" button to quickly post this article on your Wall.
blog comments powered by Disqus
The Hollywood Reporter

About Risky Business

  • Risky Biz blog takes a deep, daily look at the film industry's ups, downs and deals from around the world and the heart of Hollywood. It is edited by media and entertainment journalist Steven Zeitchik, with contributions from The Hollywood Reporter's worldwide team of film editors and reporters. Zeitchik is a Los Angeles-based writer for THR and also has written for The Wall Street Journal and The New York Times.

    Subscribe to feed